Nichols on Art and Christ
Summarizing his findings with regard to art and human beings in the final chapter of his book, Redeeming Beauty: Soundings in Sacral Aesthetics, Aidan Nichols says the following:
Art has been a feature of human society since prehistoric times. [...] Art discloses what we think our society is like, or what it is not like but ought to be like. As the main expression (other than childbirth) of human creativity it can be said to take further the original creation by bringing into being new realities of intrinsic worth. Above all, it is or can be a pointer to transcendence in three main ways. The first [...] by making us go beyond interpretations of this or that thing or event toward an overall reading of the world. The second was to see the world as having as its own precondition a fundamental meaningfulness beyond itself. The third (after we had noted the possible moral effects of art in making us go beyond the limits of our present character) was that art might be regarded as a kind of epiphany of divine presence, divine light. [...] The arts reveal the human world, either as it actually is or as it ideally is. They express the creativity of man when the artist adds to the things of intrinsic worth in the world, or the art-appreciating public makes the artist’s vision of what he has made live again. The arts point to transcendence, not just the way the world as a whole is wonderful and presupposes a meaning greater than itself, but also by enacting divine presence sustaining the special density of meaning that art, literature, music can contain (pp. 145-146).
Nichols then relates his findings to three aspects of the person and work of Jesus Christ. First of all, Christ makes manifest or reveals what humanity is. “As the true Adam, he shows us the reality of what the human species should be like and on the Cross discloses the range and power of the evil which inhibits our being as the first Adam was meant to be, in God’s image and likeness” (p. 148). So Christ reveals what the postlapsarian world is like and (thankfully) what it ought to be like. Second, Christ’s redemptive work transcends nature “by bringing into being a further dimension of reality,” viz., salvation and “new resources of grace and life” (p. 148). In other words, just as art advances and elevates creation, so too does the work of Christ. Third, in Christ the meaning of the world as a whole is revealed and points to the “Father’s wonderful plan to bring about the nuptials of heaven and earth, the uncreated and the created, in the sacrificial joy of the Kingdom. He points to the source of the world in a pre-existing divine truth, [...] Moreover, he enacts that truth-the truth which is the Holy Trinity-in his own person” (p. 148). Though only the Son took on flesh, the Son is eternally “co-defined by the Father and the Holy Spirit.” Hence, “Jesus is always the Trinitarian Son, essentially related to the Father and the Spirit in his work on earth” (p. 148). In fact, the whole redeemed creation shall one day enter into the eternal dance of the Trinity, as captured in Rublev’s famous icon of the Trinity (p. 148).
The risen and ascended God-man is the true predestined goal of all creation. Here the capacity of artwork to be the vehicle of divine presence in the material form of words or sounds or shapes and colours is super-filled. Christ is, then the perfect art work in the sense of that reality in whom is realized those goals that all artistic making has as its explicit or implicit ends. Because he is infinite meaning, life and being perfectly synthesized with finite form, the cave-painters at Lascaux, or Hesiod penning his hymns, or Beethoven working on his last quartets, were all gesturing towards him through they realized it not (p. 148).
8 Responses so far
9:46 pm
Cynthia, thanks for the posts on Nichols. I was very much interested to see how where he would end up. Although I can say I’m entirely happy. I’ve probably read too much Wolterstorff to be content with any theory of aesthetics that emphasizes expression over participation and/or action. I wonder if you’ve read the article by Jeremy Begbie in the newest Books and Culture. I hope to get around to writing about it this week.
Also, as you were following my series on Lubac’s “On Christian Philosophy”, I finally managed the time to finish the series. Last post here.
Kindest regards,
Dan
7:45 am
Hi Dan,
Things have been busy this week with school, work and family, but I hope to read your post on de Lubac this weekend.
I haven’t read the new Begbie book, but I am definitely a fan of his. Do let me know if you write up a post on his new book.
Best wishes,
Cynthia
6:23 am
Cynthia, I head the business thing. My profs keep shoving more books my way, so between family, reading, classes, AND constantly looking for the best price on all these books, it’s been hectic. I should clarify, however, that I’m always a big fan of accumulating a bottomless pile of books.
3:22 pm
Dear Ms Nielsen,
I recently stumbled on your blog and was pleased to read excerpts and your comments on Nichols’ book as well your entries on Maritain and Bulgakov, and the essay you posted at another site entitled “What Makes Music Beautiful?” These things suggest to me you might be able to answer a question of mine.
I am interested to find out if anything has been written on art and sentimentalism, broadly understood — possibly from a theological viewpoint, but not necessarily so.
Please excuse me if this seems intrusive in any way.
Cheers,
Sean
3:28 pm
Hi Sean,
Would you specify what you mean by sentimentalism?
Best wishes,
Cynthia
4:08 pm
Cynthia,
That was fast!
I was afraid you would ask that. I suppose the definition is what I’m pursuing, but in the context of art. My workaday definition of sentimentalism in this context is something that exists to call people into emotional states for that sake only, with nothing beyond. Emotion for emotion’s sake.
Thanks
Sean
5:45 pm
Hi Sean,
I haven’t read the book myself, but perhaps Leonard B. Meyer’s book Emotion and Meaning in Music would be of help and would contain bibliographic resources that might be of interest.
Best wishes,
Cynthia
6:19 pm
Thanks for your help!
Sean
Leave a comment